Former partner and Carey law firm end lengthy arbitration: firm paid $620 million for "reasonable compensation"

rss · La Tercera 2026-11-17T15:15:55Z es
With a bank transfer made last week to the account of his former partner Claudio Lizana, the Carey firm definitively closed the high-profile arbitration in which both had been involved since 2023. The legal conflict had erupted following the lawyer's departure from the firm, amid strong disagreements with the firm's management. The arbitration was originally in the hands of lawyer Ricardo Peña, but was later taken over by Ricardo Escobar (a partner at ESYF Abogados), who focused on resolving the economic compensation aspects established in the shareholders' agreement for the departure of a partner. The arbitration, which was governed by the terms of the law firm's shareholders' agreement, lasted more than two years: it began on July 1, 2024, and concluded this past September 25. While the original claim sought 179,262 UF ($7.34 billion), the arbitral award granted only the so-called "reasonable compensation" contemplated in the firm's partnership agreement, which, after deducting the amounts corresponding to the clients the lawyer took with him, set the payment at 13,884 UF ($574 million), a figure that, after adjustments and interest, came to $620 million. In his decision, the arbitrator found that Lizana took clients he served at Carey, two of which, as Pulso confirmed, are Brinks and Mastercard, in addition to two other smaller ones. The arbitral ruling rejected the rest of Lizana's claims, who was seeking compensation for moral damages, for lack of substantiation. The original amount demanded by Lizana of 179,262 UF ($7.34 billion) was broken down into 146,897 UF ($6.074 billion) in damages and 32,365 UF ($1.338 billion) for moral damages. Originally, before leaving the law firm, Carey offered his former partner an economic compensation amounting to just over $500 million, an amount that already took into account the fact that Lizana was taking two clients to his future firm. In the arbitration, the Carey law firm was advised by Aldo Molinari and Ricardo Reveco, both partners of the same firm. Meanwhile, Claudio Lizana was represented by Ciro Colombara, a partner at Estudio Colombara. The arbitrator, Ricardo Escobar, also a former director of the SII, is a former partner of Carey whose name was established as one of the possible arbitrators in case of disagreements among the firm's partners. The ruling, which does not order either party to pay costs, establishes as a mandatory condition maintaining confidentiality about its contents, so neither party wished to comment for this article. Carey, Chile's largest law firm, operates from six floors of the Titanium Tower in Santiago with a legal staff of 600 professionals, including 44 partners. The firm, founded in 1905 in Antofagasta by Francisco Carey (1873-1946), faced, in addition to the Claudio Lizana case, a labor lawsuit with lawyer María José Martabit over "gender discrimination," which was resolved through a settlement in March 2022. The pending dispute Despite the end of the arbitration, the firm and its former partner maintain another dispute in ordinary courts. Before the 6th Civil Court of Santiago, Claudio Lizana sued his former employer, claiming to be a victim of defamation. The case remains under seal. In that lawsuit for extracontractual liability, lawyer Lizana claimed damages of $1.1 billion, targeting the moral and reputational harm generated internally within the firm. This after having been, according to him, excluded from the firm without much explanation or respect for the partnership agreement, a decision that damaged his professional image. Currently, this trial is in the evidence stage, awaiting the completion of pending expert reports for a first-instance ruling to be issued. In his civil lawsuit, Lizana detailed that the conflict with the Carey firm began on October 6, 2022, when the firm's managing partner, Jaime Carey, informed the lawyer of his exclusion from the firm. "This forced exclusion was carried out not only brutally and without decorum, but also in open violation of the exclusion procedure expressly established in the partnership agreement, which requires, for the exclusion of a partner with more than 3 years of seniority: the favorable vote of at least 80% of the total partners; and that the exclusion had been proposed by the Executive Committee or by partners representing at least 30% of the total partners," the filing noted. According to the same document, "none of these formalities was fulfilled at the time of our client's exclusion, given that, as Jaime Carey acknowledged in the meeting held on October 6, 2022, the decision was only agreed upon with the most senior partners, without a formal vote being held among the rest of the partners." Are you already a subscriber? Log in This article is exclusive to subscribers Subscribe to read it in full and access all our journalism. View plans NEWSLETTER Pulso PM Monday to Friday, 12:30 PM The most relevant news on markets, companies and business: timely information, context and content to make better decisions. By signing up you are accepting La Tercera's Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policies.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight