On Tuesday morning, the Special Investigative Commission (CEI) into the management of former Minister of Public Security Trinidad Steinert voted and approved the document with the conclusions reached by the body, amid questions over the minister's absence.
It is worth recalling that former minister Steinert was invited on repeated occasions to participate in the commission, but she excused herself every time.
The commission voted between two conclusions, one drafted by the president of the CEI, deputy Raúl Leiva (PS), and six parliamentarians, and another by deputy Fernando Ugarte (Republican Party), with the first of these chosen by six votes in favor and four against.
Despite the favorable vote, there is dismay in the opposition, given that the former minister never attended the commission and that no constitutional accusation was brought against her due to the composition of the investigative commission.
Main conclusions of the commission
In the document approved by the commission, they detail that the former minister was invited on six occasions (August 17 and 31; September 7, 21 and 28; and October 5), while the former Undersecretary of Crime Prevention was invited on four occasions, and neither of the two appeared before the commission.
Likewise, they state that the commission sent a questionnaire to the President of the Republic to clarify certain background information, but it also did not receive a resp…
AI Brief
Your highlights
On Tuesday morning, the Special Investigative Commission (CEI) into the management of former Minister of Public Security, Trinidad Steinert, voted and approved the document containing the conclusions reached by the body, amid questions over the minister's absence. It should be recalled that former Minister Steinert was invited on repeated occasions to participate in the commission, but she excused herself every time. The commission voted between two conclusions, one drafted by the president of the CEI, Deputy Raúl Leiva (PS), and six parliamentarians, and another by Deputy Fernando Ugarte (Republican Party), with the first of these being chosen by six votes in favor and four against. Despite the favorable vote, there is dismay in the opposition, given that the former minister never attended the commission and that no constitutional accusation was brought against her due to the composition of the investigative commission.
Main conclusions of the commission
In the document approved by the commission, they detail that the former minister was invited on six occasions (August 17 and 31; September 7, 21 and 28; and October 5), while the former Undersecretary of Crime Prevention was invited on four occasions, and neither of the two appeared before the commission. Likewise, they state that the commission sent a questionnaire to the President of the Republic to clarify certain background information, but received no response either.
Regarding the conclusions, they first maintain that the former Minister of Public Security would have failed to fulfill the legal function of advising the President on the formation of High Commands, promotions and retirements of the police forces. As they argue, "if the former minister did not participate in the decision to call for the retirement of General Prefect Consuelo Peña, the only possible conclusion is that the former minister did not fulfill the first function to which she is called by law with respect to the Public Order and Security Forces."
Likewise, they point out that the former minister "exceeded the powers granted to her by law," stating that "beyond the administrative criticism made by the Comptroller's Office, those invited to this special investigative commission attest to the exceptional nature and inadvisability of a request for information of this nature in light of the organic law of the Ministry of Public Security."
In the same vein, regarding the request for information, they mention that "former minister Trinidad Steinert violated the principle of administrative integrity and failed to fulfill her duty of abstention."
Likewise, regarding the Government's security plan, although it was mentioned by various guests of the commission, they state that "there is no evidence of the existence of a program or security plan of the administration of President José Antonio Kast upon taking office." "As of the date of this report, no concrete background information or specific documents have been provided showing the existence of such a plan or program for the management of public security and crime prevention," they state.
In the report, they also point out that "the presidential advisory office reports that they do not have the function of approving legal documents issued by the Ministry of Public Security, without prejudice to having personnel who carry out those functions." As they mention, "there are two possible conclusions, both of special gravity: either the presidential advisors did not exercise the functions for which they are hired, or having exercised them, they were not truthfully reported to the Investigative Commission, and therefore, to the Chamber of Deputies."
"The lack of clarity about the participation and responsibilities of the presidential advisors hinders the oversight function of this Honorable Chamber, weakens the transparency and accountability of Government decisions, which is especially serious when it involves matters relating to public security," they state.
Finally, they point out that "there is evidence of a lack of control over the functioning of the Ministry of Public Security during the management of former minister Steinert, as well as a lack of knowledge and supervision of the decision of the General Director of the Investigative Police to proceed with the retirement of Prefect Consuelo Peña without any instance having requested background information, reports or justifications of the advisability of said decision."
In this way, the report puts forward a series of recommendations, including establishing a protocol for requesting information from the police forces, clarifying the functions of the presidential advisors, and establishing mechanisms to prevent conflicts of interest.