Correa Sutil distances himself from AC's arguments for sentence reductions against Rabat: "It has no merit"

rss · La Tercera 2026-11-17T12:57:05Z es
The former minister of the Constitutional Court (TC) and former Undersecretary of the Interior under Ricardo Lagos's government, lawyer Jorge Correa Sutil (ex-DC), distanced himself from some of the opposition's arguments in the constitutional accusation against Justice Minister Fernando Rabat. The brief seeking to remove the Secretary of State, driven by the caucuses of deputies from FA, PS, PC, PL, PPD, and DC, totals 189 pages and is divided into three chapters: the first, for the reduction of sentences for sexual crimes against children and adolescents; the second, for the reduction of sentences for those convicted in human rights cases; and the third, for statements by Minister Rabat in which he would have lied or provided biased information about the case. In a conversation with the program Desde La Redacción on La Tercera, Correa distanced himself from the arguments of the first two chapters of the document drafted by the progressive forces. Regarding the first, he pointed out: "I believe that is an accusation that should not succeed. The law was enacted in 2022, and there is a legitimate doubt, it seems to me, as to whether that prohibition on granting the benefit applied to crimes committed before 2022 or not. The case law has said one thing and has said another, and therefore, it seems to me that saying there is a clear violation of the law is not true. It has no merit." "It is said, look, because the minister did not consider the superior inter…
Former Constitutional Court (TC) minister and former Undersecretary of the Interior under Ricardo Lagos's government, lawyer Jorge Correa Sutil (ex-DC), has distanced himself from some of the arguments of the opposition in the constitutional accusation against Justice Minister Fernando Rabat. The brief seeking to remove the Secretary of State, promoted by the benches of deputies from FA, PS, PC, PL, PPD and DC, totals 189 pages and is divided into three chapters: the first, for the reduction of sentences for sexual crimes against children and adolescents; the second, for the reduction of penalties for those convicted in human rights cases; and the third, for statements by Minister Rabat in which he would have lied or given biased information about the case. In a conversation with La Tercera's program Desde La Redacción, Correa distanced himself from the arguments in the first two chapters of the document drafted by the progressive forces. Regarding the first, he noted: "I believe that is an accusation that should not succeed. The law was enacted in 2022 and there is a legitimate doubt, it seems to me, as to whether that prohibition on granting the benefit applied to crimes committed before 2022 or not. Case law has said one thing and said another, and therefore, it seems to me that saying there is a clear violation of the law there is not true. It has no merit." "It is said, look, the minister did not consider the best interests of the child. I think it is true that the minister did not consider it, did not weigh it, did not say that was a value. But if the accusation is that for that reason the minister had to deny the permits, that argument does not convince me. The best interests of the child is not an absolute good in law. There is no absolute good in law," he stressed. In the case of the second section, on the reduction of sentences for crimes against humanity, he stated: "If you think there is a duty of the State to respect, as a general doctrine, a ruling of the Inter-American Court, then there is already a violation of the law. If you consider that that so-called conventionality duty does not exist, that Chilean public officials must comply with the Chilean constitution and laws, and must naturally be attentive to interpreting them in accordance with the Inter-American Court, but that they are not obligated to respect it, then there is no violation of the law." "I am one of those who believes in the second thesis, that there is no obligation to respect doctrines as general doctrines of what the Inter-American Court has ruled," he maintained. On the contrary, for the former TC minister, the third chapter of the accusation against Rabat is the most solid and serious. "It seems to me that the minister did indeed commit that offense, that when trying first to exculpate himself in the decrees themselves, then before public opinion, and then before the Constitution committees of the Senate and the Chamber, the minister falsified the truth, made a ploy in order to exculpate his responsibility, stating two things that are not true," he noted. The first, he said, is that the Secretary of State asserted before Parliament that "he was bound by the Court's case law, in conditions where the case law does not bind, and there was no case law either." And second, "that he was bound by the review committees of the Ministry of Justice that examine these cases, which is also not true, because although it could be understood that the committees qualify the facts, the minister certainly then had to determine with complete freedom whether this case fell within the exceptions or not, and that is not determined by the committees." "Therefore, the minister cannot say either of the two things, neither that he was bound by the committee, nor that he was bound by the case law. In that, the minister was untruthful, and I believe there is a breach of integrity," he concluded. See the full interview here:

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight