The EU should introduce its own taxes to discourage the consumption of harmful products such as tobacco and strengthen its ability to compete with the US and China, Czech MEP Luděk Niedermayer said in an interview. A member of the centre-right European People's Party (EPP), Niedermayer is a former vice-governor of the Czech central bank and vice-chair of the European Parliament's committee on economic and monetary affairs.
The 2024 report of former Italian prime minister Mario Draghi delivered an unflattering assessment of the EU's competitiveness. Do you fear that divisions between national capitals in the EU means the union will have to rely on enhanced cooperation more often?
Luděk Niedermayer: I would not describe enhanced cooperation as something to fear — in many cases, it is a useful solution when all countries simply do not agree on something that would in fact move the EU forward.
As an MEP, I worked on a mechanism to promote equity financing for companies instead of loans. In my view, that mechanism is very good and has clear economic justification. It stalled in the Council, blocked by the unanimity requirement for tax matters.
"National leaders declare their support for Draghi's findings, but do precisely the opposite in negotiations on the European budget."
But if, through enhanced cooperation, a workable concept could be created for a group of countries without undermining the single market, it would clearly add value.
The same applies to the so-called 28th legal regime [EU Inc]. If someone offered me a choice between a weak compromise and a strong regime for half of the EU's member states, I would choose the latter.
The red line is fragmentation of the single market itself, for instance by protectionist barriers between member states. It cannot be that someone says: 'I am in the single market, but I do not import apples from Poland,' or, 'I am in the single market, but I will not import cars from Czechia and Slovakia.'
That would be the end of the road, but nobody is considering that.
So what follows from this?
The Draghi report focuses on key European sectors for economic growth. Many member states blame their economic failures on EU regulations, while other countries operating within the same legislative framework achieve excellent results, prosper and reduce their debt.
National leaders declare their support for Draghi's findings, but do precisely the opposite in negotiations on the European budget. [Another former Italian prime minister] Enrico Letta's report on the single market is equally crucial. It outlines changes that could be implemented more quickly.
You are working on the 28th regime with former Slovak prime minister and current Renew MEP Ľudovít Ódor with the aim to enable companies to grow without having to hire dozens of tax advisers in each EU country. Given that taxation falls within national competence, is it realistic to establish a workable model?
I consider the EU Commission's initial proposal to simplify the establishment of companies across borders good. Digitalisation, simplification and acceleration are a good direction to take as a starting point.
I do not think it is essential for the 28th regime to be used by tens of thousands of companies across the EU; it would be most effective for start-ups and expanding companies, for which the costs of extending across Europe are greatest. Limiting this regime to a specific type of company in exchange for its high effectiveness is an acceptable compromise.
Looking at the wider business environment, 60 of the world's 100 largest companies are from the US and fewer than 20 are European. And Chinese giants are growing faster than us. Why is Europe unable to produce global giants like Google or Anthropic?
One reason we are absent from these rankings is that the rapid growth needed took place in the IT sector, where Europe simply fell asleep. Parts of our economy and politics remained stuck in the analogue era, and we did not realise how important this was.
"The rapid growth needed took place in the IT sector, where Europe simply fell asleep."
And when high-quality IT know-how emerged in Europe, it moved to the US at a certain stage of growth. I see three reasons for this.
What are those three reasons?
First, the US has an incomparably larger financing market than the EU.
Second, other legal environments are more certain. The US state Delaware has created the world's best commercial legal system, under which most large US companies are incorporated. Not because of taxes, but because of legal certainty. Delaware has a commercial law system that no one can match.
Third, non-EU markets have higher demands for new players. The US market is far more willing to buy products from young start-ups, while Europe prefers established suppliers.
But I will add a caveat: a larger company does not mean a better company. Our weakness in the IT sector has cost us economic growth and created a dangerous technological dependency.
The Draghi report warns of Europe's strategic vulnerabilities in raw materials, chips and security. How should the EU respond to Chinese dominance in these fields?
China has made good decisions and backed them with massive state aid for industrial sectors. This would not be possible in Europe.
China also disregards ethical and environmental standards in extracting raw materials. But its technologies are of high quality.
There are areas in which we can benefit from the fact that China has invested heavily and produces an excess supply of quality goods.
Solar panels are one example. Cheap solar panels are helping us move towards achieving our climate goals.
In critical sectors, we must use a combination of supportive and protective measures to build our own capacity or diversify suppliers.
Where there are unfair state subsidies, we must impose duties to offset them, but not blanket protectionism, the cost of which consumers would bear in the form of higher prices for goods.
Chinese technology is also a threat...
In terms of security, we must ask ourselves the extent to which there is a risk that China will use technology as a weapon, like [Russian president] Vladimir Putin does with gas.
We must be careful not to use security arguments as a pretext for closing the market. We would deprive ourselves of competition that could bring down the prices of goods. If we neglect this, it also becomes a security risk.
Czech EPP-group MEP Luděk Niedermayer (Source: Tomáš Benedikovič, Denník N)
Is the growth of China's electric-vehicle sector a threat to the automotive industry in Eastern Europe?
I have the impression that this concern stems from the situation a few years ago. Dependence on batteries has gradually decreased thanks to dozens of new investments and research projects in the EU, although it remains significant. In 10 to 20 years, recycling will play a key role, reducing dependence on raw materials.
European carmakers made a huge strategic mistake by suppressing the development of electric vehicles and promoting combustion engines.