Listen: What do France’s centre-right candidates want for Europe?

rss · EUobserver 2026-11-17T09:04:25Z en
Production: By Europod, in co-production with Sphera Network. EUobserver is proud to have an editorial partnership with Europod to co-publish the podcast series “Briefed” hosted by Léa Marchal. The podcast is available on all major platforms. Find the full transcript below: In the race for the French presidential election, there are already four names on the centre-right: Gabriel Attal, Bruno Retailleau, David Lisnard and Édouard Philippe. For now, they haven’t reached an agreement to join forces and put forward a single candidate. But do they share the same vision of Europe? None of these candidates question France’s membership of the European Union, or the fundamental rules governing it. Nor do they call for changes to the EU treaties, unlike some other candidates. The differences are more about how critical they are of the EU’s current functioning. For example, both David Lisnard and Bruno Retailleau believe the European Commission sometimes goes beyond its original remit. Retailleau wants to make it possible to bring cases before the Court of Justice of the European Union when the commission is accused of overstepping its powers. Lisnard, meanwhile, wants to strengthen the role of the Council and the European Parliament, which he considers more legitimate institutions. Read more What Marine Le Pen and Alice Weidel are planning for Brussels He also takes a particularly strong stance on national sovereignty. He opposes situations in which EU law prevents member states from taking certain decisions. When that happens, he believes the question should be put to the people through a referendum. As for the biggest issue of the moment, the EU’s multiannual budget, none of the four candidates has set out a clear position on the size of the EU budget, or on how much France should contribute to it. This is quite different from Marine Le Pen’s pledge to halve France’s contribution to the EU budget. You won’t find anything of the sort in the centre-right candidates’ programmes. Édouard Philippe puts considerable emphasis on mobilising private investment to finance innovation. That’s a position often associated with the more fiscally conservative EU member states: rather than injecting more public money into the economy, they want to make better use of private savings. Gabriel Attal takes a somewhat different approach. For example, he proposes a common European artificial intelligence policy, backed by its own dedicated budget, much like the Common Agricultural Policy. Read more Europe’s youth take to the streets as the post‑war promise of a better life breaks down And he explicitly suggests that this could be financed through common European borrowing. Speaking of the Common Agricultural Policy, do they agree on what should happen to EU farming subsidies? Very much so. All four candidates place considerable importance on the CAP and want to protect France’s share of the funding. That’s hardly surprising: France is one of the biggest beneficiaries of the Common Agricultural Policy, which provides substantial financial support to French farmers. When it comes to agriculture, there’s one proposal from Bruno Retailleau that stands out: he doesn’t want Ukraine to join the EU’s agricultural market. This isn’t particularly surprising, actually. Many Europeans share this view, especially in countries where agriculture plays a major role. But unlike Retailleau, the other centre-right candidates don’t openly state this position. And what about Ukraine more broadly? Do they have clear positions on the war and European support? All in all, yes, although they don’t go into much detail. Their programmes are almost silent on this issue. Read more Europe’s centre parties are collapsing – and, for the first time, the far-right are collaborating, rather than fighting However, their public statements are clear: all four have consistently supported Ukraine, including through weapons deliveries and the possible use of frozen Russian assets to finance the country’s reconstruction. They also agree on the need to strengthen Europe’s defence capabilities. One way to do this, they argue, is to give preference to European-made military equipment. In other words, European countries should prioritise buying weapons and defence systems from European manufacturers rather than relying on American suppliers. Gabriel Attal talks about this extensively, and Édouard Philippe also explicitly supports the idea. Attal goes a step further, proposing an investment fund specifically designed to support small and medium-sized businesses in the defence sector. So, while the four candidates don’t have identical programmes, their overall vision of Europe is relatively similar. The main differences lie in how they want to reform the EU institutions, finance common priorities and protect national sovereignty.
Production: By Europod, in co-production with Sphera Network. EUobserver is proud to have an editorial partnership with Europod to co-publish the podcast series “Briefed” hosted by Léa Marchal. The podcast is available on all major platforms. Find the full transcript below: In the race for the French presidential election, there are already four names on the centre-right: Gabriel Attal, Bruno Retailleau, David Lisnard and Édouard Philippe. For now, they haven’t reached an agreement to join forces and put forward a single candidate. But do they share the same vision of Europe? None of these candidates question France’s membership of the European Union, or the fundamental rules governing it. Nor do they call for changes to the EU treaties, unlike some other candidates. The differences are more about how critical they are of the EU’s current functioning. For example, both David Lisnard and Bruno Retailleau believe the European Commission sometimes goes beyond its original remit. Retailleau wants to make it possible to bring cases before the Court of Justice of the European Union when the commission is accused of overstepping its powers. Lisnard, meanwhile, wants to strengthen the role of the Council and the European Parliament, which he considers more legitimate institutions. He also takes a particularly strong stance on national sovereignty. He opposes situations in which EU law prevents member states from taking certain decisions. When that happens, he believes the question should be put to the people through a referendum. As for the biggest issue of the moment, the EU's multiannual budget, none of the four candidates has set out a clear position on the size of the EU budget, or on how much France should contribute to it. This is quite different from Marine Le Pen's pledge to halve France's contribution to the EU budget. You won't find anything of the sort in the centre-right candidates' programmes. Édouard Philippe puts considerable emphasis on mobilising private investment to finance innovation. That's a position often associated with the more fiscally conservative EU member states: rather than injecting more public money into the economy, they want to make better use of private savings. Gabriel Attal takes a somewhat different approach. For example, he proposes a common European artificial intelligence policy, backed by its own dedicated budget, much like the Common Agricultural Policy. And he explicitly suggests that this could be financed through common European borrowing. Speaking of the Common Agricultural Policy, do they agree on what should happen to EU farming subsidies? Very much so. All four candidates place considerable importance on the CAP and want to protect France's share of the funding. That's hardly surprising: France is one of the biggest beneficiaries of the Common Agricultural Policy, which provides substantial financial support to French farmers. When it comes to agriculture, there's one proposal from Bruno Retailleau that stands out: he doesn't want Ukraine to join the EU's agricultural market. This isn't particularly surprising, actually. Many Europeans share this view, especially in countries where agriculture plays a major role. But unlike Retailleau, the other centre-right candidates don't openly state this position. And what about Ukraine more broadly? Do they have clear positions on the war and European support? All in all, yes, although they don't go into much detail. Their programmes are almost silent on this issue. However, their public statements are clear: all four have consistently supported Ukraine, including through weapons deliveries and the possible use of frozen Russian assets to finance the country's reconstruction. They also agree on the need to strengthen Europe's defence capabilities. One way to do this, they argue, is to give preference to European-made military equipment. In other words, European countries should prioritise buying weapons and defence systems from European manufacturers rather than relying on American suppliers. Gabriel Attal talks about this extensively, and Édouard Philippe also explicitly supports the idea. Attal goes a step further, proposing an investment fund specifically designed to support small and medium-sized businesses in the defence sector. So, while the four candidates don't have identical programmes, their overall vision of Europe is relatively similar. The main differences lie in how they want to reform the EU institutions, finance common priorities and protect national sovereignty.
Highlight