The ruling party will attempt this Tuesday to take its first firm step toward advancing the electoral reform project. More than six months have passed since the text arrived in the Senate, and the latest effort to crown its initiative—with the intention of overturning the PASOs, a central part of the re-election plan—has been focused since day one on negotiations with governors. The central offer, which has been circulating as a poll for some time, recreates the mechanism of collector lists, which was eliminated seven years ago during periods of dispute between Mauricio Macri and Peronism with the CFK seal. It is a mirror that few, for different reasons, would want to look into: this applies to libertarians, allies, and Kirchnerists.
The fluctuations regarding electoral rules are a classic feature of Argentine politics. And, once again, they tend to put the narrative of the ruling parties into crisis. The return of collector lists—explained as a limited version of the version repealed by decree in 2019—does not fit the discourse according to which the Executive's proposal would seek to improve electoral practice.
The details circulating in LLA and opposition media indicate that, finally, the reformulated text includes the suspension of primaries—replacing the elimination—and the reinstatement of collector lists so that in the provinces two lists of national legislators can coexist with the same presidential candidate. That, at the national level, would give room to boost deputies and senators...
AI Brief
Your highlights
Diego Santilli, along with governors. Long negotiation over the primary elections. The ruling party intends to take its first firm step this Tuesday to advance the electoral reform project. More than six months have passed since the text arrived in the Senate, and the latest effort to crown its initiative—with the intention of overturning the primary elections, a central part of the re-election plan—has been revolving since day one around negotiations with governors. The central offer, which has been circulating as a poll for some time, recreates the mechanism of colector lists, which was eliminated seven years ago during the disputes between Mauricio Macri and Peronism with CFK backing. It is a mirror that few, for different reasons, would want to look into: this applies to libertarians, allies, and Kirchnerists alike. The ups and downs regarding electoral rules are a classic feature of Argentine politics. And, once again, they tend to put the official party narrative in crisis. The return of the colector lists—explained as a restricted version of the version repealed by decree in 2019—does not fit the discourse according to which the Executive's proposal seeks to improve electoral practice. The reports circulating in LLA and opposition media indicate that the reformulated text finally includes the suspension of the primaries—replacing their elimination—and the reinstatement of colector lists so that in the provinces, two lists of national legislators can coexist with the same presidential candidate. This, at the national level, would allow room to promote deputies and senators who run with local leaders and not as part of the purple blocks. This is a question at the provincial level. The broad sense of the deals to avoid LLA disputes with friendly governors and the commitments of district funds, ranging from social security debts to works and discretionary transfers, remains to be seen. The understanding should be sealed during the Senate committee treatment this Tuesday, although there is still a chance to make the final adjustments on the way to the chamber: in the official party's ideal plan, the session should be secured for next Thursday. An alternative that is not ruled out is that, if LLA fails to gather all the signatures to support the resolution without reservations, it could proceed with support in dissent from some dialogue proponents, perhaps from a provincial space and from ranks of PRO and UCR. In that case, Diego Santilli would need an additional effort to reach the session with a closed package. The Chief of Staff is in charge of that task, based on the line set by Karina Milei. And there, as in other areas, the internal conflict between Olivos and Patricia Bullrich surfaces. The former minister and head of the ruling party senators transmitted several times that she can operate to agree with allies and dialogue proponents on the pace of the legislative process—committee and chamber—but the work with the governors, to align the legislators who respond to them, is the responsibility of Santilli. And also Luis Caputo. Patricia Bullrich, leading the bloc in the Senate, moves with her own dynamic. "Finished," summarizes a man who closely follows the conversations and has dialogue with those involved on both sides in the negotiations. He refers to the vote count to crown the project with the two points mentioned as the axis. He highlights the statements made in recent hours by provincial heads who have fluid dialogue with the Government. Of course, no one risks it if the support is already truly committed to add a special majority in the chamber, meaning 37 legislators. The issue of the quid pro quo between the Executive and the governors to advance the electoral reform was already making it difficult to sustain the anti-establishment discourse, although it was maintained against the legislative reality of the ruling party, which does not have its own majority in either chamber. In the first term, Milei maintained generic charges against "the" politics, focusing on Congress. But laws had to go through the path of negotiations and, in many cases, with acceptance of changes or pruning of articles. The point is that the recycling of lists that converge behind a single candidate, nationally, had already exposed much debate at the end of the Macri government, with strong pressure from the PJ, especially in the province of Buenos Aires. The then president eliminated the possibility of installing colector lists by decree, a path that had been enabled by Cristina Fernández de Kirchner in 2011. Now, they point out as a difference that the replenishment of the system is restricted, because it establishes a maximum of two lists and the use of the Single Paper Ballot, among other issues, according to what has been reported. More complicated is the exposure of the governors who let know their intention to close a deal in those terms with the national ruling party. The central argument for liquidating the primary system is as follows: eliminate state spending on a mechanism designed to resolve internal party or political coalition disputes; avoid a premature electoral test, which can affect the economy even before the first round, and remove an overload of votes from ordinary people. Viewed this way, that goes against the signals of many provincial heads, who are willing to advance local elections, meaning decoupling them from the national schedule. That depends politically on the will of the local ruling parties, except in cases of obligation for constitutional reasons. The Government is in a race against time to secure the process in the Senate and immediately accelerate in the Chamber of Deputies, with the goal of having the law sanctioned before the end of the year. The deadline is related to a specification from the Electoral Chamber. Even if everything works as the Government bets, the final inconvenience could be the judicialization of the colector list issue. This is something warned about by the opposition, although it would also add signals from the circle of Patricia Bullrich. Libertarian tension surfaces differently in Congress. In Mileismo, they do not hide annoyance at the message with which the former minister presented something like a counterpoint of agendas. When the Government began disseminating that electoral reform occupies the first line of priorities, Bullrich highlighted that the disability law would be sanctioned this Thursday. Signs of internal conflict.