Jorge Fernández Díaz's analysis of the visit of León XIV: "He came to break a bubble of hegemonic narrative"

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-17T04:06:33Z es
The journalist and writer Jorge Fernández Díaz analyzed the political and social impact of Pope Leo XIV's visit to Argentina and the message he conveyed. Interviewed by Carlos Pagni Monday night on Odisea Argentina (LN+), he maintained that the Pontiff "broke a bubble" and that his statements should challenge both the ruling party and the opposition. "I lost faith. Being agnostic is accepting the idea that one cannot understand divinity and mystery. It is good to have faith, and that is why I envy you. In any case, a Pope came who is centrist and said he believes in the private sphere and in institutions, but that a series of things are needed," Fernández Díaz expressed. The journalist highlighted the Holy Father's stance and stressed that if someone else had delivered his message, they would have been accused of being "leftist, socialist, and communist." "What he was saying was something sensible, which seems very old. He came to break a bubble of hegemonic narrative where everything sounded old," he continued. Along these lines, he asserted that the Pope's discourse must challenge both Milei—who, according to him, "lost touch" with the focus of the message—and Peronism. "He left an audience seated but no actor," he said, and wondered, "Will Massa embody social Christianity and care? Kicillof? I don't think he is Peronist yet; I see him as a *trosko* student from college. He struggles to sing the march." Later, Fernández Díaz...
Journalist and writer Jorge Fernández Díaz analyzed the political and social impact of Pope Leo XIV's visit to Argentina and the message he conveyed. Interviewed by Carlos Pagni on Monday night on Odisea Argentina (LN+), he argued that the Pontiff "broke a bubble" and that his statements should challenge both the ruling party and the opposition. "I lost my faith. Being agnostic means accepting the idea that one cannot understand divinity and mystery. It's good to have faith, and that's why I envy believers. In any case, a Pope came who is centrist and said he believes in the private sector and in institutions, but that a series of things are needed," said Fernández Díaz. The journalist highlighted the Holy Father's stance and stressed that if the person delivering that message had been someone else, they would have been accused of being "a leftist, a socialist, and a communist." "What he was saying was something sensible, though it seems very old-fashioned. He came to break a bubble of hegemonic narrative where everything sounded old," he continued. Along these lines, he asserted that the Pope's message should challenge both Milei — who, according to him, "disregarded" the focus of the message — and Peronism. "He left an audience seated, but there are no actors," he said, and asked himself: "Is Massa going to embody social Christianity and care? Kicillof? I don't believe he's really a Peronist yet; I see him as a Trotskyist kid from university. He struggles to sing the Peronist anthem." Later, Fernández Díaz remarked ironically that "it seems the Pope never came," referring to the fact that, when he was in the country, his presence generated a bit of harmony that has since evaporated. Meanwhile, he noted: "Argentina felt an impressive popular stirring full of concepts. I am a resigned agnostic, always envying faith, and I felt something personal. That night with the young people, something impressive of spirituality was experienced." Argentine politics On another front, Fernández Díaz spoke about the current state of Argentine politics. Among the main points, he referred to the role of Propuesta Republicana (PRO), a party he considered to have "bowed too much" to Milei. "They have been very opportunistic and have surrendered absolutely to Milei-ism," he explained. Fernández Díaz said that the Pope's message challenges both Milei and Peronism. Martín Lucesole However, he also clarified that, although it had "bad results," Cambiemos was "unjustly" accused of being part of a "traditional rustic right and the heirs of Martínez de Hoz." "It was terrible bad faith. They were also accused of dropping the bomb in '55, which is absurd," he said, noting that their project consisted of a new liberalism that sought to embody what was done in Spain, Canada, and Australia. "They wanted a centrist country. A lot of market and as much state as possible," he concluded. The journalist also took aim at Milei, whom he accused of "rushing to confirm all the prejudices." "Suddenly he talks about 'the right,' a word that was scorched by the military dictatorships. In that, he succeeded," he emphasized. Fernández Díaz questioned the idea that Milei was "sincere" during his election campaign and argued that it "is relative" because "he promised several things he ultimately did not do." He asserted that the President built an image for himself and recounted: "He belonged to the América group, did everything possible to undermine the Cambiemos government, and ran with Scioli in 2015. He told Alberto Fernández he was not an anti-Peronist and allied himself with the Menemists. In other words, there is a certain confusion around who Milei is and the idea that he is pure." "Milei is not as republican as is claimed. In fact, he believes institutions are a caste and distrusts them. To some extent, he is Menemist. They detest Parliament," he continued. Then, Fernández Díaz recounted that during Kirchnerism, Cristina Kirchner criticized journalism, accusing it of questioning her because it was against her ideals, and called it "sham republicans." Referring to that concept, the writer stated: "This place is full of them: journalism, leaders of Radicalism and the PRO. They are indeed sham." Finally, he closed with a critique of the premise of Milei's government and the electorate's perception: "We went from a 'state for all' to the idea that the state should not exist. It's absurd. That liberalism swallows that curve and ties itself to Milei with everything that implies behind it is somewhat regrettable."

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Highlight