Some Russian magnates yearn for a return to the oligarchic system of the nineties, when businessmen enjoyed power. Is there any chance that it could become a reality?
AI Brief
Your highlights
Image source, Getty ImagesAuthor, Vitaly ShevchenkoAuthor's title, Chief Analyst, BBC MonitoringPublication date 14 minutes agoReading time: 11 minHours after launching his full-scale invasion of Ukraine on 24 February 2022, Vladimir Putin gathered Russia's richest men in the cavernous Yekaterininsky Hall of the Kremlin. More than thirty people huddled against a wall, wearing masks because of the Covid pandemic. A Russian journalist described them as "pale and tired-looking". As he entered, Putin sat on the opposite side of the hall, creating a great distance between himself and the businessmen. As usual, he wore no mask. Using his characteristically cryptic language, he said he expected them to support the war."I would like to ask you to show understanding of what is happening," he said, "and to work together with the government to find the tools that support production, the economy and employment." In the video of the meeting released by the Kremlin, none of the invited billionaires uttered a word. That silence has become a hallmark of Russia's super-rich. During Putin's decades in power, they learned that the price of speaking up could be very high. Skip More reads and continue readingMore readsEnd of More readsIn 2003, oil magnate Mikhail Khodorkovsky, then the richest man in Russia, who financed several opposition groups, accused Putin of presiding over rampant corruption. He spent the next ten years in prison, convicted of tax evasion, fraud and embezzlement — a warning to other potential critics. He denied the charges. Image source, ALEXEY NIKOLSKY/SPUTNIK/AFP via Getty ImagesCaption, The silence of Russian businessmen at a Kremlin summit with Putin in 2022 perhaps demonstrated their fear of the president. And although some of the magnates opposed the war, they usually kept their opinions to themselves. But even in that silence, murmurs can be heard: some members of Russia's once-powerful business elite seem to imagine a Russia without Putin. They wonder whether, once the president leaves office or dies, the country could come to resemble what it was like in the 1990s — when the oligarchs enjoyed the fruits of power — or even whether a healthier politics could take root. Journalist Arkady Ostrovsky, a prominent Kremlin watcher at The Economist, who recently spent hours interviewing one of Russia's richest men, senses that a "historic political shift" is taking place in how the ultra-rich view the country's future. Restless magnatesThe collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 gave rise to a new and powerful force in the domestic political landscape: people who took advantage of the end of communism and became extraordinarily wealthy, and who then sought to control politicians for their own benefit. They were called "oligarchs", a term that in ancient Greek means "the few who rule". They had money, which at that time meant power. This era of the turbulent 1990s was when the so-called "new Russians" burst onto the scene. Large state-owned enterprises were up for grabs, and men with the right connections became millionaires — even billionaires — almost overnight. Corruption spread, cronyism ran rampant, and contract killings were frequent. But almost immediately after being elected president for the first time in 2000, Putin subdued the oligarchs. He had little interest in sharing power with anyone else. He could afford to take on the billionaires because the Russian economy was recovering and the central government was strengthening. Image source, NurPhoto/NurPhoto via Getty ImagesCaption, Some oligarchs developed a distinctive style of dress in the 1990s, as later satirized by this artist from St Petersburg. Bill Browder, a financier who was the largest foreign investor in Russia and was banned from the country in 2005 after campaigning against corruption, says the Russian magnates cowered and bowed to Putin, for example at the Davos economic forum in the years before the war, when they were still welcome there."I remember seeing oligarchs strutting around as if they owned the place, arrogant, self-assured individuals. And then Putin appeared, and it was astonishing to see how these individuals, supposedly alpha males on steroids, turned into submissive children, almost desperate," he told the BBC. Since the outbreak of the war in 2022, the Kremlin has kept Russia's richest businessmen in line with a relentless policy of rewards and punishments. Critics of the war have had their assets confiscated, while the loyal have been rewarded with lucrative government war contracts: today there are more Russian billionaires than ever (155 in total, according to Forbes magazine). Their collective wealth has reached a new high of nearly $700 billion. But even for those magnates who have remained loyal and been rewarded, all that money does not seem to make them happy. Some are beginning to grow impatient.Autocracy, oligarchy or democracy?Their billions no longer go as far as they used to: domestically, they cannot buy much political influence."In this game they have no cards," says exiled politician and analyst Dmitry Nekrasov. "They are rich because they have some relationship with Putin, not the other way around." And outside Russia they are marginalized because of the Western sanctions imposed on Russia after its full-scale invasion."They are treated like petty criminals. They can't fly in their private jets. Their yachts can't dock in the best ports in Europe. It must be terrible and humiliating for them," says Browder, the outspoken Putin critic. So, discreetly, some are beginning to wonder what will happen when Putin leaves the political stage. That is what well-informed analysts immersed in the world of these magnates tell me. There is no immediate prospect of the president's departure, nor any reason to think his health is fragile. However, Putin, who turned 74 last month, has served in the Kremlin for a quarter of a century; in Moscow they know his departure will come one day. When Reuters asked him last year whether he intended to stay in office until 2036, the date his constitutional term ends, Putin replied: "Only God knows whether we will have enough health." Image source, CARL DE SOUZA/AFP via Getty ImagesCaption, One of the most prominent oligarchs of the 1990s was Boris Berezovsky, who fell out with the Kremlin and spent his final years in the United Kingdom. If Putin resigned or died in office, Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin would assume power. However, Mishustin has shown no presidential ambitions (probably why he was appointed). This would create a power vacuum. If this happens, the Russia experts I have spoken to foresee several possible scenarios. Some in the West, and undoubtedly in Russia as well, cherish the hope that democracy will flourish in a post-Putin Russia, with a government led by the people rather than by a new clique of oligarchs or a single autocrat. However, according to analysts, this seems to be the least likely path. The main democratic institutions have been weakened or destroyed during Putin's tenure."Russia is so used to violence that it has become unaccustomed to conventional democratic procedures," says Alexandra Prokopenko, an exiled Russian journalist and analyst. Another path is greater autocracy. A different figure could replace Putin and continue his culture of repression. But Prokopenko believes it would not be another authoritarian dictatorship, at least not immediately. These things take time, she says: at first, Putin's successor would be weaker than him and would have fewer resources. And then there is the third option: that the magnates reassert their power and Russia returns to a system similar to the oligarchy of the 1990s. From "boss" to "grandpa"Dmitry Nekrasov, a former Kremlin adviser and opposition politician now living in exile, says that in this scenario the country would be governed by a handful of powerful elite clans allied with business interests. This last option, of course, is the one many magnates desire."They want to return to a time when they were listened to, when their assets were not taken away from them, and when they understood the rules of the game," says Prokopenko, who has spent a great deal of time talking with Russia's richest people. Although their power has been severely diminished since the 1990s, the magnates are still worth listening to: given their immense wealth, it seems likely that sooner or later they will try to reassert their political influence. According to Nekrasov, the exiled politician, some are already trying to befriend the right security officials or ministers. However, he says, going one step further is too dangerous. Image source, Vladimir Smirnov SPUTNIK/KREMLIN POOL/EPA/ShutterstockCaption, Putin has kept the magnates under control with a ruthless carrot-and-stick policy since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine. According to Nekrasov, the magnates' behavior in the coming years will depend in part on their financial situation. Those with abundant liquidity will have more confidence to "play politics" and position themselves strategically, preparing for a post-Putin country. Those whose wealth depends on state contracts or government favor, on the other hand, will be too afraid of losing everything. Prokopenko says a shift can already be noticed in the way businessmen talk about Putin. They used to nickname him "Nachalnik" (which translates as "boss"), "Perviy" ("the first") or by his initials "VV" — all nicknames denoting a certain respect. Now they call him "Ded", which Prokopenko describes as "a disdain". "Ded" translates as "old man" or "grandpa", a much less reverent name. According to her, some wealthy Russians long for a "return of politics to people's lives", with less repression, greater freedom of expression and healthier competition between parties and politicians. But, she adds, for the moment they are too afraid for that to happen because of the oppressive atmosphere prevailing in Russia. Prokopenko interviewed a magnate who sat on his phone throughout the conversation, because he believed this would make it harder for the secret police to digitally eavesdrop."It seemed to me a fear worthy of the Stalin era. It is totally irrational," she says. An explosive interviewAn interesting clue about what the magnates might want from a post-Putin future came from Andrey Melnichenko, known as the world's fertilizer king and currently the eighth richest man in Russia. Earlier this year, he surprised everyone by giving an interview to The Economist — unusual for a wealthy Russian, especially to a publication from a country the Kremlin considers hostile. They also published an essay written by him. At some points in the interview, Melnichenko repeated the Kremlin's arguments. He claimed that Ukraine is a battleground between Russia and the West, and that, in his view, the West ignores Russia's security concerns and threatens its sovereignty. But then things got more interesting. Melnichenko did not call for Putin's resignation, but — and this is a crucial point — he advocated for a change that would end the one-man regime in Russia. He said Russia needs to engage more with the world. Prokopenko believes the magnate was trying to generate a public debate. It was a "call to the rich like himself to start speaking up," she says. The journalist who interviewed him, Arkady Ostrovsky, tells me that the two had "tense and heated discussions" in "hotels and cafés, where they drank coffee, a lot of coffee, and sometimes smoked". He says the magnate seemed to be "sincerely reflecting" on his answers, rather than resorting to political tactics. In Russia nothing is simple, and most observers believe the interview probably had some kind of approval — implicit or explicit — from the Kremlin. We do not know why the authorities would have so enthusiastically authorized this unusual call for change; they may have been trying to demonstrate that some degree of pluralism still exists in the country. No magnate came out to support it. Even so, the journalist believes Melnichenko was speaking not only for himself, but also for his fellow businessmen. Image source, Andrey Rudakov/Bloomberg via Getty ImagesCaption, Some magnates feel marginalized because of Western sanctions, unable to fly in private jets and visit Western resorts like Saint-Jean-Cap-Ferrat, in the south of France, which used to be popular among wealthy Russians. Some cherish the hope that, after Putin's departure, the country will become an "oligarchic republic", as journalist Ostrovsky describes it, something like what it was in the 1990s, with the business elites in charge. Based on his years reporting on Russia, Ostrovsky says many of the country's billionaires currently feel a "sense of dead end, the product of what this war has done to Russia... [an] absence of future". But even if the magnates are thinking about the future, it seems unlikely they will act soon. Browder, the Putin critic, says that while many of them are discontented, it is unlikely they will conspire against Putin while he is still alive."They understand that if they did anything that defied Putin, he would kill them. And Putin is a very paranoid little man." Mike Calvey, an American financier who was a key investor in Russia, agrees."What can they do apart from going straight to prison and losing their assets? It's easy for those in London to say: 'Why don't you all rise up and go straight to prison?' That is exactly what would happen." Russia's richest men used to have great influence at the highest levels of power. Once Putin leaves power, they will undoubtedly try to regain their former influence. The question is: will the remnants of the current regime allow them to?This article was originally written in English and we used an artificial intelligence tool to translate it. A BBC journalist reviewed the text before publication. More information about how we use AI. Download the new BBC World Service app. Choose BBC News Mundo and receive news alerts, documentaries and analysis, all in one place. Important: the new app is not available in the United Kingdom or the United States.