The civic campaign to demand changes in judicial auctions reached the Senate

rss · La Nacion 2026-11-16T22:58:10Z es
The national campaign under the slogan "For an independent justice," aimed at demanding greater transparency, predictability, and equality in the selection processes for the Judiciary, arrived at the Senate this Monday, through a letter sent to the strategic Agreements Committee, which is in charge of debating the lists of judges sent by the Executive Branch. The entities that are part of the campaign invoked their constitutional right to "petition the authorities" to demand that senators "when signing the opinions corresponding to the designation of federal or national judges," they "consider and weigh the circumstance of the candidate's merit ranking before and after the personal interview conducted by the National Council of the Judiciary." The missive is part of the action of a transversal coalition composed of civil entities, bar associations, business chambers, and legal experts, which promote immediate reforms in the evaluation system managed by the National Council of the Judiciary, with the purpose of guaranteeing a procedure based on objective merit. The central focus of the demand consists of requiring the Council of the Judiciary to modify the selection regulations to limit the interference of discretionary evaluations. Specifically, the signing organizations request "to limit the incidence of the interview to a maximum of 20 points..."
The national campaign under the slogan “For an Independent Justice,” aimed at demanding greater transparency, predictability, and equality in the selection processes for the Judiciary, arrived at the Senate this Monday through a letter sent to the strategic Agreements Committee, which is responsible for debating the lists of judges submitted by the Executive Branch. The entities participating in the campaign invoked their constitutional right to “petition the authorities” to demand that senators “when signing the opinions corresponding to the designation of federal or national judges,” they “consider and weigh the circumstance of the candidate's merit order before and after the personal interview conducted by the National Council of the Magistracy.” The missive is part of the action of a cross-cutting coalition composed of civil entities, bar associations, business chambers, and legal experts, who are promoting immediate reforms in the evaluation system managed by the National Council of the Magistracy, with the goal of guaranteeing a procedure based on objective merit. The central focus of the demand is to require the Council of the Magistracy to modify the selection regulations to limit the interference of discretionary evaluations. Specifically, the signatory organizations request “limiting the impact of the interview to a maximum of 20 points on the result, in line with what has been proposed by the Supreme Court of the Nation.” According to the document presented, minimizing the margin of discretionary decision-making constitutes “the first step toward guaranteeing judicial independence,” a condition they define as the institutional basis and key input for promoting investment, growth, and employment. “The citizenry has perceived that the merit order arising from the objective contests conducted by the Council is often absolutely altered after the interviews due to the discretion of the procedure. This has warranted a ruling from the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation, which proposes limiting the valuation of the personal interview to 20% of the total score, so as not to displace the merit of the contests conducted. In the same vein, some of the most prestigious entities of civil society and the exercise of law have issued a joint statement. We attach both documents,” the signatories stated in the letter addressed to Senator Maximiliano Abad, a member of the Agreements Committee. A project to limit the weight of personal interviews in the contest score had been presented by two Supreme Court justices, Carlos Rosenkrantz and Ricardo Lorenzetti, last March. But so far, it remains stalled within the Council of the Magistracy. The discretion in evaluating personal interviews has allowed candidates with low scores in written exams and in their background to end up in favorable positions to be included in the shortlists from which the candidates proposed by the Executive Branch emerge. The campaign, made visible through the hashtag #MasMeritoMasJusticia (More Merit, More Justice), is promoted through a public petition on the Change.org platform. It highlights the critical diagnosis of the current functioning of evaluations. In a statement, the promoters point out that, although the Constitution requires suitability, independence, and efficiency in the designation of judges, today “different criteria are used to decide who reaches the personal interview, which ends up being defined by discretionary criteria, and the merit of the contest is rendered void.” The "For an Independent Justice" campaign. In this sense, they emphasize the legal obligation of the evaluating body to strictly respect the merit order arising from the applicants' academic exams and background. The presentation is supported by civil society and judicial organizations such as the Civil Association for Equality and Justice (ACIJ), the Center for Implementation of Public Policies for Equity and Growth (Cippec), the Political Action Network (RAP), the Argentine Political Club, Poder Ciudadano, the Bar Association of the City of Buenos Aires, and the Argentine Federation of Bar Associations (FACA). Furthermore, private sector entities joined, including the Institute for Business Development in Argentina (IDEA), the Argentine Industrial Union (UIA), the Argentine Business Association (AEA), the Argentine Rural Society, and the Chamber of Commerce of the United States in Argentina (AmCham). Among the jurists and constitutionalists who supported the initiative are Roberto Gargarella, Daniel Sabsay, María Angélica Gelli, Juan Carlos Cassagne, and Antonio María Hernández. Public figures and political leaders also joined the initiative, such as Rogelio Frigerio, Esteban Bullrich, Hernán Lacunza, Ernesto Sanz, Ramón Lanús, Luciano Laspina, Juan Manuel López, Nicolás Massot, Gabriela Michetti, Liliana Negre de Alonso, Graciela Ocaña, Adrián Perez, Omar Perotti, Federico Pinedo, Florencio Randazzo, Margarita Stolbizer, María Eugenia Talerico, Martín Yeza, Soledad Acuña, Oscar Aguad, Eduardo Amadeo, Marcela Campagnoli, Susana Decibe, Facundo del Gaiso, Rodrigo de Loredo, Mónica Fein, and Emmanuel Ferrario. “For the reasons stated and because we believe that citizens have the right to impartial and suitable justice, one that aligns with the parameters of objective merit provided for by the National Constitution, we request that, in the exercise of your popular, provincial, and national representation, you thoroughly review and consider the possibility of not granting agreement to candidates whose merit has been substantially altered in relation to the initial contest order,” the signatories stated.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight