Production: By Europod, in co-production with Sphera Network.
EUobserver is proud to have an editorial partnership with Europod to co-publish the podcast series “Briefed” hosted by Léa Marchal. The podcast is available on all major platforms.
Find the full transcript below:
Bomb threats, election interference, espionage, and sabotage. Cyberattacks are becoming an increasingly serious threat across Europe, affecting everything from public services to critical infrastructure. So, how prepared is Europe to deal with them?
Let’s start with the scale of the threat. What’s been happening recently? Just last week, we’ve seen a wave of bomb threats across Europe. The latest target was Eurostar, which received a bomb threat on Thursday.
Before that, schools in Italy, Ireland and Scotland had also been targeted. And we’ve seen attacks affecting all sorts of things, from aircraft to refrigerators.
Now, these incidents don’t all have the same consequences. Some cause economic disruption, while others turn out to be hoaxes. But cyberattacks can also be used for election interference.
Read more
EU Commission to host security talks after week of bomb hoaxes that hit 20 airports and dozens of European flights
Are we as vulnerable as it sometimes seems? Well, the EU has developed a number of tools to tackle cyber threats. But there are still some significant weaknesses.
Take cooperation, for example. The EU has established several mechanisms to help countries and institutions share information and coordinate their responses. Because this is crucial when it comes to such coordinated attacks.
But in September, the European Court of Auditors published a rather critical assessment. It concluded that EU action only partially facilitates the detection of and response to major cybersecurity incidents.
Information sharing is still limited, reporting procedures have weaknesses, and there are considerable delays in putting some of the mechanisms into operation.
Even within a single country, several different authorities may be responsible for cybersecurity. So the challenge is to make sure they all follow compatible procedures and can communicate as smoothly as possible.
Before coordinating anything, you need to focus on preventing attacks. Here the idea is to make systems as secure as possible, so that attacks can be prevented or their impact limited. This is an ongoing effort, at every level.
The EU Agency for Cybersecurity, ENISA, plays an important role here. It provides guidance to public authorities and businesses, helps identify emerging threats and supports the development of more secure digital products and services.
The EU has also introduced legislation to set minimum cybersecurity requirements. One of the main pieces of legislation is the NIS 2 Directive, which has been in force since October 2024. It requires organisations operating in critical sectors, such as energy, transport, healthcare and digital infrastructure, to put security measures and procedures in place to manage cyber risks and respond to incidents.
Read more
Divided EU cyber defence faces real-life Russian and Chinese threats
And is it working? Are these sectors actually becoming better protected? Well, there are signs of progress, but the picture is uneven. ENISA regularly assesses the cybersecurity maturity of Europe’s critical sectors.
In its latest assessment, it found that sectors such as electricity, telecommunications and banking are relatively well prepared.
But it also identified significant weaknesses in other areas, including healthcare, gas, maritime transport, public administration, space and information and communication technologies.
So the level of protection still varies considerably depending on the sector. Beyond prevention, there’s the question of responding to an attack. Have Europeans learned to react quickly enough?
Here again, they’re working on it. Every year, EU member states and the European Commission take part in large-scale cybersecurity exercises. These simulations are designed to test how authorities respond to major incidents and identify weaknesses in their coordination.
But in real life, response times can vary enormously, depending on the type of attack and how sophisticated it is. And sometimes, simply identifying who’s behind an attack can take a long time.
Take the incidents involving the manipulation of the temperatures in refrigerators in France, for example. It took around a month to identify the suspected perpetrators, in this case a group linked to the Iranian regime.
Read more
Listen: When does a hybrid attack become an attack on Nato?
And there’s another figure worth keeping in mind. According to Google’s Mandiant cybersecurity research, the median time an attacker remained inside a compromised system before being detected was 14 days worldwide in the latest figures cited here.
All in all, despite the growing number of agencies, regulations and initiatives dedicated to cybersecurity, the threat keeps evolving.
And the biggest challenge isn’t necessarily a lack of tools or money. The EU is investing heavily in cybersecurity, including around €1.4bn through its Digital Europe programme over the current budget period.
The real challenge is making sure all these tools work together.
AI Brief
Your highlights
Production: By Europod, in co-production with Sphera Network.
EUobserver is proud to have an editorial partnership with Europod to co-publish the podcast series “Briefed” hosted by Léa Marchal. The podcast is available on all major platforms.
Find the full transcript below:
Bomb threats, election interference, espionage, and sabotage. Cyberattacks are becoming an increasingly serious threat across Europe, affecting everything from public services to critical infrastructure. So, how prepared is Europe to deal with them?
Let’s start with the scale of the threat. What’s been happening recently? Just last week, we’ve seen a wave of bomb threats across Europe. The latest target was Eurostar, which received a bomb threat on Thursday.
Before that, schools in Italy, Ireland and Scotland had also been targeted. And we’ve seen attacks affecting all sorts of things, from aircraft to refrigerators.
Now, these incidents don’t all have the same consequences. Some cause economic disruption, while others turn out to be hoaxes. But cyberattacks can also be used for election interference.
Are we as vulnerable as it sometimes seems? Well, the EU has developed a number of tools to tackle cyber threats. But there are still some significant weaknesses.
Take cooperation, for example. The EU has established several mechanisms to help countries and institutions share information and coordinate their responses. Because this is crucial when it comes to such coordinated attacks.
But in September, the European Court of Auditors published a rather critical assessment. It concluded that EU action only partially facilitates the detection of and response to major cybersecurity incidents.
Information sharing is still limited, reporting procedures have weaknesses, and there are considerable delays in putting some of the mechanisms into operation.
Even within a single country, several different authorities may be responsible for cybersecurity. So the challenge is to make sure they all follow compatible procedures and can communicate as smoothly as possible.
Before coordinating anything, you need to focus on preventing attacks. Here the idea is to make systems as secure as possible, so that attacks can be prevented or their impact limited. This is an ongoing effort, at every level.
The EU Agency for Cybersecurity, ENISA, plays an important role here. It provides guidance to public authorities and businesses, helps identify emerging threats and supports the development of more secure digital products and services.
The EU has also introduced legislation to set minimum cybersecurity requirements. One of the main pieces of legislation is the NIS 2 Directive, which has been in force since October 2024. It requires organisations operating in critical sectors, such as energy, transport, healthcare and digital infrastructure, to put security measures and procedures in place to manage cyber risks and respond to incidents.
And is it working? Are these sectors actually becoming better protected? Well, there are signs of progress, but the picture is uneven. ENISA regularly assesses the cybersecurity maturity of Europe's critical sectors.
In its latest assessment, it found that sectors such as electricity, telecommunications and banking are relatively well prepared.
But it also identified significant weaknesses in other areas, including healthcare, gas, maritime transport, public administration, space and information and communication technologies.
So the level of protection still varies considerably depending on the sector. Beyond prevention, there's the question of responding to an attack. Have Europeans learned to react quickly enough?
Here again, they're working on it. Every year, EU member states and the European Commission take part in large-scale cybersecurity exercises. These simulations are designed to test how authorities respond to major incidents and identify weaknesses in their coordination.
But in real life, response times can vary enormously, depending on the type of attack and how sophisticated it is. And sometimes, simply identifying who's behind an attack can take a long time.
Take the incidents involving the manipulation of the temperatures in refrigerators in France, for example. It took around a month to identify the suspected perpetrators, in this case a group linked to the Iranian regime.
And there's another figure worth keeping in mind. According to Google's Mandiant cybersecurity research, the median time an attacker remained inside a compromised system before being detected was 14 days worldwide in the latest figures cited here.
All in all, despite the growing number of agencies, regulations and initiatives dedicated to cybersecurity, the threat keeps evolving.
And the biggest challenge isn't necessarily a lack of tools or money. The EU is investing heavily in cybersecurity, including around €1.4bn through its Digital Europe programme over the current budget period.
The real challenge is making sure all these tools work together.