TO THE EDITOR:
The debate over the maritime route between Punta Arenas and the Falkland Islands leads to the need to determine what obligations Chile has and whether these force it to choose between Argentina and the United Kingdom.
In August 1992, Aylwin and Menem signed a joint declaration in which Chile endorsed the Argentine legal position on the Falklands, South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands, and described the resolution of the dispute as a matter of "permanent hemispheric interest." Kast reiterated this this year, and as a state associated with Mercosur, Chile signed a declaration in June that questions Britain's unilateral exploitation of resources in the disputed area.
Do these declarations bind? The International Court of Justice has acknowledged that a unilateral act binds a state when it expresses its intention to be bound, and good faith, a fundamental principle of public international law, prevents acting against one's own acts.
With the United Kingdom there are treaties in force, a formal source of international law, that bind Chile; the 2021 Association Agreement and the CPTPP. Would asking permission from Buenos Aires not imply recognizing an authority that it does not currently exercise over the islands?
The dilemma is clear, even if the answer is not. Either Chile asks authorization from Buenos Aires and honors its commitment, or it trades with the islands under the protection of its treaties and assumes the cost of failing to comply with what it has declared.
Macarena Fernández Undurraga
Professor of International Law, Universidad Central
AI Brief
Your highlights
Comments
TO THE EDITOR:
The debate over the maritime route between Punta Arenas and the Falkland Islands leads to the question of what obligations Chile has and whether these force it to choose between Argentina and the United Kingdom. In August 1992, Aylwin and Menem signed a joint declaration in which Chile endorsed the Argentine legal position on the Falklands, South Georgia and the South Sandwich Islands, and described the resolution of the dispute as a matter of "permanent hemispheric interest." Kast reiterated this this year, and as a State associated with Mercosur, Chile signed a declaration in June questioning unilateral British exploitation of resources in the disputed area.
Do these declarations bind? The International Court of Justice has acknowledged that a unilateral act binds a State when it expresses its intention to be bound, and good faith, a fundamental principle of public international law, prevents acting contrary to one's own acts. With the United Kingdom there are treaties in force, a formal source of international law, that bind Chile: the 2021 Association Agreement and the CPTPP. Would asking permission from Buenos Aires not imply recognizing an authority that today it does not exercise over the islands?
The dilemma is clear, even if the answer is not. Either Chile asks authorization from Buenos Aires and honors its commitment, or it trades with the islands under the protection of its treaties and assumes the cost of not fulfilling what it has declared.
Macarena Fernández Undurraga
Professor of International Law, Universidad Central
More about:
Chile
Argentina
United Kingdom
Treaties
Obligations