MR. EDITOR:
Former minister Hernán Larraín warns in his recent column about a series of errors in the sentence-reduction case, and describes the bill repealing Law 19,856 as an aggravation of the problem. I agree with him that this debate requires prudence. That is why it is worth reviewing what the bill proposes and what it does not.
Let us start with the law that is sought to be repealed; sentence reduction is not an exit under control; once the discount is applied, the sentence is considered served. The convict is left without supervision for the time discounted, and the possibility of revocation if he reoffends does not exist.
Expanding the exclusions to other crimes does not solve the problem either. The 2022 reform, signed by Larraín as minister, generated controversies over its application and rulings in opposite directions. This is part of the current crisis.
Repealing this law does not mean abandoning reintegration. Exit permits and parole are maintained, for which a psychosocial report is required, it provides for the participation of victims, and keeps the sentence in force, under supervision and with obligations whose breach allows the benefit to be revoked. The bill separates two things that are currently confused: incentives for reintegration, which are maintained, and the uncontrolled early extinction of the sentence, which is eliminated.
Reintegrating is, as Mr. Larraín says, an act of humanity. So is protecting victims and giving them the certainty that the sentences q…
AI Brief
Your highlights
Comments
MR. EDITOR:
Former minister Hernán Larraín warns in his recent column about a series of errors in the sentence reduction case, and describes the bill that repeals Law 19.856 as an aggravation of the problem. I agree with him that this debate requires prudence. That is why it is worth reviewing what the bill proposes and what it does not.
Let us start with the law that is sought to be repealed; the sentence reduction is not an exit under control; once the discount is applied, the sentence is considered served. The convicted person is left without supervision for the discounted time, and the possibility of revoking it if they reoffend does not exist.
Expanding the exclusions to other crimes does not solve the problem either. The 2022 reform, signed by Larraín as minister, generated controversies over its application and rulings in opposite directions. This is part of the current crisis.
Repealing this law does not mean abandoning reintegration. Exit permits and parole are maintained; the latter requires a psychosocial report, provides for the participation of victims, and keeps the sentence in effect, under supervision and with obligations whose breach allows the benefit to be revoked.
The bill separates two things that are currently confused: incentives for reintegration, which are maintained, and the uncontrolled early extinction of the sentence, which is eliminated.
Reintegrating is, as Mr. Larraín says, an act of humanity. It is also an act of humanity to protect victims and give them the certainty that the sentences imposed by the courts are served.
The reference to Shakespeare is apt, but the risk is Hamlet: doubting indefinitely while the problem repeats itself. This bill, promoted by senators of different sensibilities, seeks precisely to cut that chain. It has my support.
Cristián Vial Maceratta
Senator of the Republic
More about: Sentence reductions, Bill, Crisis