They were there and they remain in the same place with the same dissatisfactions, deprivations and, above all, the same orphanhood. But now they are much more visible, they have recognizable faces and they express audible voices, forming a relevant and numerous collective.
The papal visit illuminated them, concentrated them, put them in an unmistakable foreground, impossible not to be seen. The new orphans of politics are a reality of Argentine citizenship, who constitute (or should constitute) a new concern for the ruling party seeking the reelection of Javier Milei and for the leadership of the various party factions or pre-candidates without a party who will attempt to dethrone him in next year's presidential elections.
Everything indicates that this is an update of the socio-political category that, based on the effects of the 2001 crisis, was instituted by sociologist Juan Carlos Torre in his now-classic work titled Los huérfanos de la política de partidos (The Orphans of Party Politics). That paper, subtitled "On the scope and nature of the crisis of party representation," explained how the "que se vayan todos" ("throw them all out") of that time mainly affected non-Peronism, but damaged almost everyone. A quarter of a century later, the voids return corrected and enlarged.
Several field surveys and polls conducted in the days before and during the hyper-attended presence of Leo XIV attest to the vitality and magnitude of that group…
AI Brief
Your highlights
They were there and remain in the same place with the same dissatisfactions, deprivations and, above all, the same orphanhood. But now they are much more visible, they have recognizable faces and audible voices, forming a relevant and numerous collective. The papal visit illuminated them, gathered them, put them in an unavoidable foreground, impossible not to see. The new orphans of politics are a reality of Argentine citizenship, and they constitute (or should constitute) a new concern for the ruling party seeking Javier Milei's reelection and for the leadership of the various party factions or pre-candidates without a party who will try to dethrone him in next year's presidential elections. Everything indicates that this is an update of the socio-political category instituted, from the effects of the 2001 crisis, by sociologist Juan Carlos Torre in his now-classic work titled Los huérfanos de la política de partidos. That paper, subtitled "On the scope and nature of the crisis of party representation," explained how the "que se vayan todos" of that time mainly affected non-Peronism, but damaged almost everyone. A quarter of a century later, the voids return corrected and enlarged. Several field surveys and polls conducted in the days before and during the hyper-appealing presence of Leo XIV attest to the vitality and scale of that solid and growing group of Argentines who say they lack political-party representation, as well as leaderships that inspire and convey the capacity to satisfy their demands and expectations. The origins and previous political-party affiliations of these afflicted people are remarkably heterogeneous. No space is spared. The problem cuts across the historic national cleavage of Peronism vs. non-Peronism. Among those studies, there is one that illuminates a social segment crucial for the next elections, which already had a relevant prominence during the nearly two decades of Kirchnerism, until its exhaustion and disenchantment, and which was then even more key to bringing Milei to the Presidency. It is the under-40s, "who in 2027 will represent 52.9% of the electoral roll," says Lara Goyburyu, a political scientist and executive director of the consulting firm Management & Fit (M&F). It is in that segment where, according to the firm's surveys, approval of Milei's administration fell the most compared to the rest of the population (-9.9 points versus 2.1 points), with the peculiarity that this did not translate into a wholesale migration toward any political space or figure. The absence, the void, is filled with the disenchanted who are not going anywhere, but, as also became clear these days, they are neither absent nor demobilized. They simply move and gather according to other emotionalities and rationalities. This emerges from the analysis of the papal visit made by sociologist Eduardo Fidanza, director of Poliarquía. "To conclude, at the end of the Pope's visit, that our politics [...] has lost all capacity for representation is somewhat superficial. Perhaps it can be said, instead, that the political class is mediocre —not only here but in almost all of the West— and that the impeccable, though rhetorical, message of a moral leader calls it into question, exposing its defects and insufficiency." The main and majority of the demands, as all polls without exception reveal, are economic in nature. Nevertheless, the dissatisfaction or disenchantment is not limited to that problem. On this, Fidanza adds: "Milei's future will continue to depend fundamentally on the economy, on how Peronism organizes itself, and on its willingness and capacity to generate political agreements. But his capacity to revise his leadership style will also be key. In that sense, the visit can leave a political mark. It made evident that there is a demand for greater sensitivity, closeness and support that the Government should not underestimate. [...] Thus, the Pope does not represent a direct political threat to Milei, but he did expose some of his vulnerabilities." In this way, the categories of "kukas" and "ñoño republicans" seem insufficient to explain, dismiss or discredit the opponents and critics of the ruling party, its policies and its ways. Leo XIV restored to the public agenda concepts that Milei and the hard core of his followers had managed to effectively block, thanks to their own narrative merits and the defections of their adversaries. Whoever expressed them ended up, on the one hand, anathematized in the Kirchnerist camp, which perverted or banalized those principles, generally to the benefit of its constriction of political and economic power. Or, on the other, they were relegated to the trunk of the liberals in the political-social sphere and (with their pluses and minuses) in the economic one, who out of lukewarmness or ineffectiveness missed the opportunity to transform Argentina and put it on the path of growth and development, with democratic quality. Inclusion, upward social mobility, respect for others, moderation, the aspiration for progress remain values and not disvalues for Argentines, even for those who do not practice them, but they find no political-party channels or credible leaderships to embody them. Semi-empty shelvesThe antinomies of Mileiism vs. anti-Mileiism and Kirchnerism vs. anti-Kirchnerism do not explain the current political landscape, do not synthesize the alignments and references, nor resolve social demands. They are only useful and functional to each of the terms of that equation, not to society. However, that dichotomy finds support in the sharpness of each pole, in the dominant presence of its exponents and, currently, in the existing political-electoral offer. On the shelf of the 2027 presidential elections there are two magnum-size containers, Milei's and Axel Kicillof's, and a quarter-liter bottle of Myriam Bregman's. The novelty is that around the big brands, announcements loom that cast some diffuse shadows over them. On one hand, the increasingly visible image of Patricia Bullrich and, on the other, the very powerful ghosts of Cristina Kirchner and Sergio Massa. Around the products already displayed, some free samples have begun to appear, from outsiders and aspirants of uncertain origin, whom nobody knows whether they are marketing experiments or launch announcements. Respondents therefore answer based on what is available in the market today, before the seasonal (electoral) products appear. One more reason to sustain the current orphanhood that inhabits millions of Argentines, and which nobody knows whether it will find some product to satisfy it or whether it will again opt for the one it considers least indigestible. The Karina factor emergesFaced with this reality, the Government is immediately devoted to sealing fissures and trying to block the growth of threatening factors rather than expanding its capital, both in the superstructure and in the political base. The urgent race for the elimination or suspension of the PASO primaries has that objective, but it faces the problem that to achieve it, it cannot leave out the second part of the equation. Those who must lend the votes of their legislators want to be part of the future to which they are invited to contribute, but without being assured concrete participation in eventual gains. Many of them feel that only solidarity in possible losses is guaranteed. A troubling variable in these times when critical scrutiny of the Government is increasing and there are already orphans of the ruling party, who have intensified their questioning in light of the words and manner of Leo XIV. That is the issue of discussion that agitates the interior of Mileiism and, even more, that of Karinism, which already has its own factions, embodied on one side by cousins Martín and Eduardo "Lule" Menem, and on the other by Diego Santilli. In that debate of tactics, not of ideas or practices, the Chief of Staff has recovered a certain rapport with the anti-Karinist super-advisor Santiago Caputo, with whom in other times he has shared interests and (political) actions. The presidential sister, meanwhile, is increasingly busy. First, with the construction of the presidential reelection. Then, with the expansion of party representation and the territorial anchoring of LLA, the cause of some friction with allies key to the central objective. There stand out the puzzles she must assemble simultaneously with friendly Radicalism and with the disheveled Macrismo. Finally, and much more recently, Karina Milei has taken on a task unprecedented for her. She has begun to take care of herself or, rather, of the (re)construction of her own image, which is among the most negative in the political spectrum. For now, the goal is not to establish her as a figure with electoral projection; rather, the idea of her advisors is that she stop being a drag on the President's image, already sufficiently battered and with too much ballast. A new stage. The installation of the Secretary General of the Presidency with a new profile photo (smiling and purportedly friendly) on her social media accounts is part of the complex project of turning "Cruella de Vil" into a "good fairy." In the same vein go some limited and careful public appearances (with voice), which will tend to become more frequent. Added to this is the idea of continuing to advance in some forms of media exposure, beyond the relationship with militant communicators of traditional media and new platforms. There are inscribed, rather than public interviews, some off-the-record conversations with journalists considered friendly. Experience will determine how far to advance along that line. Dealing with the severe perijournalismophobia suffered by the Milei siblings requires progressive therapy. The multiplicity of fronts exposes the narrowness and limitations of the Mileiist structure, which encourages some allies, opponents and potential contenders to explore options of alternative constructions to the existing ones, with pretensions of fishing in the heterogeneous ocean of the orphans, to add them to some base of their own. Several are engaged in that task. From those closest to Mileiism, such as the yellows, whom Mauricio Macri himself encourages to evaluate alternative paths, whether toward some option of their own or to negotiate with the ruling party from a somewhat more robust position. Also doing so are ex-Macristas now decidedly in opposition, who are sounding out Peronist shores and beaches, to the concern of the libertarian ruling party and Pro. One of the explorations that Karinists and yellows watch with the most interest has the singularity of putting the Macrist bastion of Buenos Aires City in dispute. In particular, they try to discern how far some conversations could advance between Horacio Rodríguez Larreta and the non-Kirchnerist Peronist faction commanded in the Capital by the expansionist Juan Manuel Olmos. They consider it a threat. The political-electoral reform promoted by the ruling party, whose final project is still being written to the rhythm of the negotiations led by Santilli, has entered a stage of definitions, and its resolution will activate electoral alliances and breakups to adapt to the calendar and the rules of the game that finally emerge. Then will begin the fishing season for non-captive voters, who are the ones who will define the election, with their vote or with their abstention. They are the new orphans of politics, that expanding collective that Leo XIV illuminated.