Judge Ricardo Lorenzetti: "The great revolution of the 21st century is protecting what is human"

rss · Infobae 2026-11-15T04:20:39Z es
Ricardo Lorenzetti was born in Rafaela, Santa Fe. The son of a traveling salesman and a schoolteacher, he was educated in the public university system, started at the bottom of the judicial ladder sewing case files together, and in 2004, in a different Argentina, arrived at the fourth floor of Talcahuano 550 as a justice of the Supreme Court of Argentina. When we recorded this interview at the Infobae studios a week ago, it was also a different Argentina: a couple of days later, Leo XIV would arrive in the country and turn it upside down, at least for a while. In light of this chronology and considering the issues the Supreme Pontiff brought to the national agenda, this installment of Sr. Juez offers other points of reading. Starting from The Leadership of Chaos (2025), his latest book, we talked about the crisis of the West and the value of freedom, about the self-absorption of the political class and the broken promises of the welfare state, and about building a new humanist politics that once again offers a vision of the future for everyone. In a world where technology is advancing over our decisions, our work, and our privacy, Lorenzetti says that "the great revolution of the twenty-first century is protecting the human." —I have here in my hands the third edition of your latest book, "The Leadership of Chaos." The first edition came out at the end of 2025, I imagine with writing work that took place throughout that year. However, when one looks at the content, one finds a co…
Interview with Supreme Court Justice Ricardo Lorenzetti Ricardo Lorenzetti was born in Rafaela, Santa Fe. The son of a traveling salesman and a schoolteacher, he was educated in the public university system, started at the bottom of the judicial career ladder stitching case files together, and in 2004, in a different Argentina, arrived at the fourth floor of Talcahuano 550 as a justice of the National Supreme Court. When we recorded this interview at the Infobae studios a week ago, it was also a different Argentina: a couple of days later, Leo XIV would arrive in the country and turn it, at least for a while, upside down. In light of this chronology, and considering the issues the Supreme Pontiff has brought to the national agenda, this installment of Sr. Juez takes on other layers of meaning. Starting from The Leadership of Chaos (2025), his latest book, we talk about the crisis of the West and the value of freedom, about the self-absorption of the political class and the broken promises of the welfare state, and about building a new humanist politics that once again offers a vision of the future for everyone. In a world where technology is encroaching on our decisions, our work, and our privacy, Lorenzetti says that "the great revolution of the twenty-first century is protecting the human." —I have here in my hands the third edition of your latest book, The Leadership of Chaos. The first came out at the end of 2025, I imagine after a writing process that took place over the course of that year. Yet when one turns to the content, one finds a conversation that remains current... it speaks of the state of democracy, of the state of public conversation... How do you see the health of democracies in the world? —What we are seeing today is a great disconnect between institutions and society. What we are seeing, for example, in France—the explosion of many people who do not feel included in society, who feel outside the institutions, who think that society is not there for them, that governments are not there for them—is a sign of illness. In the elections we see in almost every country, either they are very surprising, because phenomena emerge of people who begin to participate and express themselves because they feel isolated, or participation levels are extremely low. We live in a world in which the majority of people do not feel represented. It reminds me of Shakespeare's King Lear, which says that bad times are when we are led by madmen or the reckless. The recklessness of much of the political class is clearly on display, because they move forward and the people are left behind. Offices shrink people, and I try to make ideals expand them; we must work more on ideals. I worry deeply about the future of all our people. I travel a lot around the country, I go to many other countries, and I see fear, disillusionment, hopelessness. So what we have to do is raise this problem: all this leadership that talks about the past, that talks about itself, is playing with the future of our children, of young people, of the people who cannot find a place in society, who cannot find a future. It is a tragedy, and naturally they blame democracy. So democracy must be rethought. This book is largely devoted to that, because we see institutions that were designed 200 years ago, leaders who speak of those 200 years in a language completely out of its time, who talk about themselves, about their interests, and on the other side there is society. And society lives in a world that is already completely different because of technology, because of the artificial intelligence that is leaving it without work, the failure of pension systems, very young people with no future... —Those young people are the ones taking to the streets in Europe, for example. —Right, we have to talk about that. When one asks what is discussed today in the institutions, it is interests. It is as if the institutions have been co-opted by groups. That is the feeling. So I believe we bear a great responsibility. This has to be changed fundamentally. Big changes must be made, because societies need a future. I, for example... let me tell my story, right? Yesterday I was at a university and they asked me how I got to the Court. I was born in a city that had no university, that had no important courts; my father was a traveling salesman and my mother a teacher. So I had to travel to study, I had to work in courts stitching case files together. And then there were competitive examinations at the university that allowed me to enter, there were competitive examinations at the University of Buenos Aires. I was able to develop myself, I was able to get an education, and I was able to reach the Supreme Court. And if I had not reached the Supreme Court, I would have been happy in other fields. That is Argentina's social mobility. That is being lost. We have never been so close to losing social mobility, and this is tragic. And what you do not see is people with responsibilities talking about this. Nor do you see them talking about the environmental crisis... it is as if climate change is not happening here, and climate change worries us deeply—the natural resources, the situation we are leaving to so many boys and girls who will not have a future because the climate is changing at an accelerating pace. There is great irresponsibility among the leadership. I am going to start speaking out loudly. At this point, after 20 years on the Court, I can take on that responsibility, step somewhat outside my role, and speak sincerely about the concerns I have as a human being: because I have children, because I talk all the time with young people and I see them worried. I believe there are solutions, there is hope. That is what the book is about, that is what my podcast is about... I have stepped well outside my role to speak sincerely in dialogue with people, with everyone. —We see technology companies moving at full speed, and a political actor with ever greater relevance, Pope Leo XIV. Do you think the ideas of this new humanism are the axis, the column on which an idea of the future is built? —Yes. Thirty years ago we were concerned with human action on the environment. That was the Stockholm conference. Human action had put nature in a situation of crisis, and we are living it now, ever more severe. Then, in recent years, we began to concern ourselves with human action on the human being. We have never been so close to losing control of the mind. It is not so much the problem of artificial intelligence, which resembles human intelligence, but that human intelligence increasingly resembles artificial intelligence. If you ask most people, they have today lost control of their minds: they cannot sleep because the mind works and works and works, they cannot concentrate because the mind works... we have lost control of the mind, starting with the most intimate. Why? Because the cell phone dominates us and addictions are created. Let us start there, because sometimes people speak in the abstract, right? Concrete reality is lived by everyone. Boys and girls today live isolated in a digital world. That is fine in some respects, but if we do not protect them, it can generate depression; they have access to online gambling, they have access to pornography, they have access to drugs, they have access to everything a parent would not want to teach them. We are putting boys and girls at very great risk; there are suicides, depression, loneliness among young people. And among adults too. Today technology prolongs human activity, but people have nowhere to go... A person who lives to 70, 80, 90 years old, if they retire at 65, has no access to education, no access to health care, and no access to a comfortable life because they have no income. We are creating very serious social problems by failing to control technology. Artificial intelligence is very good in many respects, but there is no concern for the problems it generates. The first problem is that it is generating mass unemployment. Who is talking about this in an election campaign? Or in governments? We have to speak up and say that there are models of working with artificial intelligence, that there are green jobs, and that there are countries developing this. It is not all tragic. What is tragic is that the leadership does not address it. —Why do you think the political class is not talking about these issues? —We are living through an end of an era that is very evident. If one analyzes the political class of the last 20 years, practically no one is left; there is a very strong expiry of the political leadership. Why? Because a profound change is needed. They do not look to the future, they look to the past, they repeat the past. I always give the example of Don Quixote that Foucault cited: Don Quixote read the books of chivalry and there was no more chivalry, so he insisted, Foucault says in The Order of Things, on fighting against the world to impose the texts. That is the feeling I get. Much of the leadership speaks against society to impose something that does not exist. It is as if they are addressing an audience that has gone elsewhere. No one listens to them. This is a very important fracture that is worrying for democracy. When chaos is spoken of, here in Argentina there was much talk about a book by Da Empoli that dealt with chaos, but it is another thing, a more limited vision, because it refers to people who create chaos. It is a critique of authoritarianism, a more limited vision, and today the topic has somewhat passed. When we speak of chaos, it is that we live in a world with a multiplicity of changes happening at the same time; it is a chaotic system. So leading that means knowing how to manage many variables at once and, above all, giving people the opportunity to have a future. That means decentralization of institutions, not concentration. There are many changes that need to be made that are fundamental changes, and society is reacting everywhere. —If a leadership class were to emerge that decided to go in this direction, how can the toolbox of democratic institutions accompany or adapt to it? —The first thing that seems important to clarify is that there will be no savior. There will not be one person with the solution. The solution lies in increasing social participation. And there are many models... let us look at the optimistic side of all this, because the great problem is disillusionment. The disillusionment, the fear, the loneliness that is lived, that is palpable, is something that worries me deeply, because if people are afraid they do not act. I have often been afraid and have tried to overcome it; other times I made mistakes and corrected them. That potential of the human being is what we must recover. If we look at Argentina's great achievements, they were not born from the decision of one person; they were born in the streets. For example, the human rights movement. It was born in the streets with the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo during the dictatorship and later became a great movement that is a social consensus of Argentines. Recognized by all three branches of the state, national and provincial, and by all political parties. If we look at the movement for equality between men and women, feminism was born in the streets. I remember many years ago, with Carmen Argibay, we received a group of young women who were just starting out, and so we created the Women's Office, the Domestic Violence Office, and the association of women judges was created. Today it is a very strong movement, solid, unquestionable. That is what we must talk about, that is, help people mobilize. The same happened in environmental matters; today we have a strong environmental movement in Argentina. The problem is that there is a lack of participation, because I believe that in the design of social networks there is a purpose of making people participate in the networks and not transform reality. We call this digital smoke. —The illusion of participation. —Right. It is a bit of narcissism, isn't it? On the networks one insults, hates someone, criticizes politicians, criticizes leaders, criticizes one's friend, criticizes those who think differently, makes a tweet, a demonstration, a video, an escrache, mobilizes people with an escrache... and now all of that dissolves in a day, sometimes less. It is very instantaneous and, above all, ineffective. Societies are not transformed that way. —And how is a society changed? —In the rule of law. Because, for example, in my generation we wanted to change the world. How was it done? One participated in politics or in judicial actions. Some years ago there were many non-governmental organizations—human rights, environmentalist, women's, for women's equality, feminist, people who fight. A while ago I wrote a book where I spoke of the "perfume of epic" in Argentina. For example, there are people who work and then devote their time altruistically to fighting for things. There is a young woman I received the other day, who is a prosecutor, who saw that a bulldozer was driven over penguins. So she started a movement on her own. There are people fighting to protect whales, penguins, glaciers, all over the country; people fighting to protect equality between men and women; Argentina is full of people fighting for ideals. We talk a lot about natural resources, which are important, but Argentina's human resources are far more important; we have extraordinary human capital throughout the country. And when one looks at Argentine culture—of which little is said and little is encouraged—perhaps it is the most important thing we have. It is true that we have minerals, that we have agriculture, but Argentine human capital is extraordinary. We have a Piazzolla, we have a Borges; in every field we have people who have distinguished themselves around the world. That human capital is what is at risk. So, how is society transformed? First, give people hope, lift them out of depression, out of loneliness, out of fear, guide them, give them hope, generate movements. That is called reflective democracy, because democracy no longer takes place only within institutions, because the institutions are heavily co-opted by sectors of technology, by crony capitalism. Society must be mobilized so that it integrates into the rule of law. That is called reflective democracy—great debates in society. If we do not have those debates, there is violence. It is happening in France. What is violence? It is the frustration of not feeling in a place where real problems can be discussed—because what are the real problems? Studying, having access to housing, being free and not controlled, having a job... very simple things that no one addresses. Those are the things that worry everyone today and from which the institutions are drifting further and further away. So reflective democracy is very important. Streamline, integrate into the rule of law. The networks are important but they are not effective in terms of transformations. —You have to put your body on the line. —Yes. And it is not difficult. Argentina has had many generations of young men and women who attempted change. They became frustrated. Think of democracy in recent years: many generations of young people, men and women, who participated in political life and then became frustrated. Today there is no right to frustration; there is a right to hope, there is a right to say that we can all do something much better together if we decentralize, if every person has the opportunity to live, to develop. That is the central issue. When humanism is spoken of, it is not an abstract idea; it is a very concrete idea. The human means the opportunity to develop, and the opportunity to develop means first having basic goods, the possibility of access to health care, housing, and work. All three things are at risk. And that is what ultimately worries everyone. Whether because it is at risk personally, or for their family, their children, their friends. —And it has to do with a conversation about human dignity. —Exactly. So that is the basics. Then we have the issue of human dignity. What the Pope says—I worked a great deal with Pope Francis on this topic—the "algorethics," the ethics of the algorithm. The design of algorithms affects hate speech... insult and hate have increased in recent years because, of course, the algorithm is designed to promote it. —Designed by private companies that are also accumulating more and more power. —Exactly. So first that must be stopped. There are judicial actions; the Court has issued three rulings recently. These cases of boys and girls who are stripped naked in images, the insults, the slurs, the escraches, all of that... there are judicial actions. What needs to happen is for people to get enthusiastic and participate. But human dignity is very important. When you say there are companies... the enormous economic enrichment of many companies is because they do not pay for the raw material. What is the raw material? Our data. And the information, for example, that journalists produce—those companies do not pay for it. There must be control; we are destroying social bonds. It is not just that there is no longer any cross-pollination of different positions, but that everyone has their tribe; it is very primitive. If you ask anyone whom they talk to and relate to, it is less and less; we live isolated, and so we watch the series we always watch, the books we read are always the same, the news... a digital bubble is created in which we have no relationship with those who think differently. That diminishes us as human beings. —Tech companies need to be regulated, particularly at this moment AI companies, but there are two speeds: the speed of technological development and then the speed of institutions. In geopolitical terms there is also a global dispute over who controls the technology of the future. How can institutions face a speed that is exponential? —I think that is being done, right? There are two levels. One is among states. There are positions like those of some sectors of the United States that have a reactive policy, that is, if AI produces a negative effect, we regulate it, we react. There are others that have a proactive position, like Europe, which regulates before the problems arise. And there are others that intervene through the state, like China. And then there is getting everyone to agree, which is the hardest part. The debate already exists; the problem is effectiveness, because anyone anywhere in the world today can create something with AI and do great harm. For example, if someone had the ability to take over the refrigerators of all supermarkets and ruin all the food, that would be tragic. But what worries me more is the other level, that of each of the people listening to us who suffers from this. We must tell them that there are already actions available. If, for example, there is a boy or a girl who is attacked at school, bullied on the networks, there are actions. If an image is made of them being chased or stripped naked, there are actions. I believe in citizen participation, because changes are made that way; they are born from below. We must empower people, beyond governments. The great change, the fundamental transformation here, is born from below. —I think this whole conversation also points to the definition of the word politics: What is the meaning of politics today? —We return to basic principles, right? All this technical knowledge creates a number of benefits and a number of problems. The problems it creates are not solved with technical knowledge; they are the problems that the history of humanity has always known: unemployment, loneliness, social control. All of that has already been studied, and that is politics. There is a recovery of the classics. For example, the recent debates about the film "The Odyssey" are interesting... in the end it has two or three central themes: treating the immigrant as if he were myself—that is the law of Zeus. That is a very current theme; human rights do not belong to citizens, they belong to humans. Another theme, Plato's myth of the cave. There is a book called Why Read Plato Again?, why does it matter? When one sees that a person today believes that reality is everything they see in the digital world, Plato wrote many years ago that there are masses of people who are chained, watching the shadows, and that is not reality. It is the reality that conforms us, that soothes us, but that isolates us and ends up depressing us. Reality is to confront, to go out into the street and talk with those who think differently, to educate our boys and girls, to let them suffer something, friction, debate, because otherwise they are automatons. That is dehumanization. I believe we are in the great politics—today it is the great politics, not the politics of candidates; that is the old politics. The new politics is the organization of a more humane society, which is what Pope Francis wrote and what the current Pope has written. But these are not documents for the Catholic religion; they are addressed to humanity. And it is not only a matter of religion; there are many people on this path, as I am, working on the great politics, thinking of a more humane society. —What is happening with the West? Why are we all talking about the West? —When one looks at macro-history, there were eras when Asia dominated the world, eras when Muslims dominated Europe, eras when the West dominated Europe and dominated Asia. In macro-historical terms, these are known debates. Currently, I believe there was a crisis in the West because those values were abandoned. What are the values? First, they are the values of the Enlightenment and of classical history, especially the Greek. We are talking about philosophy, and I like to talk about that, but for people who do not like it, it means freedom... the freedom to speak, to express myself, not to be controlled. This is at stake today. Because if we let our boys and girls continue like this, their entire lives will be controlled, all of it. Because they will apply for jobs and all their personal data will be there on the net; they will voice an opinion and they will be controlled. We have already grown used to showing our faces. Digital control of the face. We have grown used to giving our data to everyone. So freedom is at risk. That is a value of the West. Much has always been fought for personal autonomy, freedom. Recovering that is very important. The division of powers, another great value of the West, is also at risk. Little by little we have grown used to the idea that judiciaries may not be independent, that we can appoint friends, that there is political influence over the judiciary. I believe that today the great values of the West are in the hands of the societies of the West, not of the leaders. That is the great clash. And the West has also worked in recent years for more plural societies, which means vigilance against religious fanaticism; we can have religions of every kind. Argentina is a model: we have interreligious dialogue, we have a very important racial multiplicity, and that must be protected. In other countries it is at risk. It is a value of the West that is at risk, because it is being debated whether there are societies that must have a particular religion, a religious law. We do not have that, and that must be valued. —The focus of the discussion about the West has not to do with an attack but rather with a revaluation of what the West has historically represented, from the canon, from its beginnings... —Yes. Here the idea of attack is tied to the idea of creating enemies. We have an extensive tradition of creating enemies, which almost everyone who has worked on the subject has written about. The best known is Umberto Eco, who wrote a book about it. He asks, "Why do we Italians fight among ourselves? Because we have not created an enemy abroad." Today partisan politics is based on the creation of enemies. We hate the opponent; he is not an opponent, he is an enemy. Within the democracy of the West that is not possible, because democracy is not that; it is not between enemies, it is between adversaries. There is a value of the West that is at risk. As for the claim that we are being invaded by different cultures... that is not a value of the West either, because the relationship among Muslims, Christians, and others has a millennia-old history. This idea of creating enemies does not work well; integration is needed, and Argentina really is a model. I believe the work that has been done on interreligious dialogue is extremely important, and it inspired Bergoglio when he was Bergoglio, before being pope, and we have a phenomenal model of social integration. Let us not buy the idea of the enemy. There is a sketch by Les Luthiers where they win the elections, create a commission to write the national anthem, visit an author and tell him, "The anthem must have power; we are going to create an enemy." The author says, "But we have no enemy." "Well, we'll create one," they reply, and then they say, "Let's fight against Norway." It is very ironic, isn't it? That is what is happening: creating artificial enemies. That is not the way. We must create common ideals, not artificial enemies. Argentina must take care of what it has. We do not have those problems. We have a great deal of integration. It really is a very valuable model. We Argentines should also be prouder of what we have. —What is power? —Power, technically defined, is the possibility of influencing another. Now, in political, institutional terms, it has changed enormously. There has always been talk of hard power, which is military power, hard power, the power to control someone because you can detain them, because you can annihilate them. That is hard power, the power of force. Then economic power, then technological power. All those powers are extremely dangerous if they are not within the rule of law, because law was conceived to limit power. The other vision is power through institutions, authoritarian power. That is not good either. Power in the rule of law must be limited. No one should have too much power, no one. Power for no one—that is the definition of democracy. So economic power, technological power, and authoritarian power must have limits and balances. That is how rule-of-law systems work. And then there is another conception of power that is more important today, which is soft power, as Joseph Nye called it, which is the power of prestige, the power of persuasion. So I believe that today the great power is that one. And that is why in the book I speak of the moral narrators of the nation. There is a book by Martha Nussbaum that speaks of the great leaders—for example, Lincoln in the United States, or Martin Luther King, or Rabindranath Tagore in India. Why were they great leaders? Because they were leaders of soft power, respected people, of prestige, who integrated the nations. They narrated a loftier narrative of great ideals—for example, humanism—that makes all people feel integrated and pursue the hope of a better world. In the end, the great task of leadership, given that there are so many changes happening at once, is to integrate them into one great idea, and the great idea is that we should be more human. To protect the human, so that we continue to think with a certain autonomy and so that we have the possibility of having a future. We were the last free generation, because from now on everyone will be controlled. Everything. We are beginning to limit ourselves in what we do because everything is on the net, all our data, everything. I believe the great revolution of the twenty-first century is protecting the human.

Translated from es by z-ai/glm-5.3-flash

Knowledge Graph

Entities
Highlight