The Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) deemed the measures to repair the damage to the indirect victim in the case of the transfemicide of Paola Buenrostro, which occurred ten years ago, as fulfilled.
As a result, the full Court dismissed as moot the incident of non-enforcement of the judgment that the victim had pursued before the highest tribunal, after it considered that the authorities of Mexico City had not fully complied with the injunction granted by a judge for the Executive Commission for Attention to Victims (CEAVI) to include compensatory measures with a gender perspective, avoiding discriminatory treatment.
During Wednesday's session, Justice Sara Irene Herrerías Guerra stated that the CEAVI issued a new ruling to comply with the comprehensive reparation ordered and verified the payment of the corresponding compensation measures during the processing of the victim's challenge.
She also noted that the District Court declared the injunction ruling as fully complied with, without excess or deficiency, but what has not yet happened is the notification to the complainant. However, she clarified that her rights to file a grievance remain intact. "The Human Rights Commission determined that its recommendation was fulfilled. I do not want it to be understood that, by issuing this vote, we are overlooking the importance that the complainant and victim has been comprehensively repaired for the damage," she stated.
Justice Hugo …
AI Brief
Your highlights
The Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) has declared the reparations measures fulfilled for the indirect victim of the case of the transfeminicide of Paola Buenrostro, which occurred ten years ago. As a result, the full Court dismissed as moot the incident of non-execution of the judgment that the victim had filed before the highest tribunal, after considering that the authorities of Mexico City had not fully complied with the amparo that a judge granted her so that the Executive Commission for Attention to Victims (CEAVI) would consider compensatory measures with a gender perspective, avoiding discriminatory treatment.
During Wednesday's session, Justice Sara Irene Herrerías Guerra stated that the CEAVI issued a new resolution to comply with the ordered integral reparation and verified the payment of the corresponding compensation measures, during the processing of the victim's appeal. She also noted that the District Court declared the amparo judgment fulfilled without excess or defect, but what has not yet happened is the notification to the complainant. However, she clarified that her rights remain intact to file a grievance.
"The Human Rights Commission determined that its recommendation was fulfilled. I do not want it to be understood that, by issuing this vote, we are overlooking the importance that the complainant and victim has had the damage repaired in an integral manner," she said.
Justice Hugo Aguilar Ortiz, president of the Supreme Court, stated that the matter is being declared moot because compliance with the judgment has taken place. In this context, the justice urged the authorities to immediately comply with the rulings of the courts and to prevent victims from having to resort all the way to the High Tribunal.
"Any complainant who has to reach the full Court for the full compliance of their judgment — that is what a tortuous route implies. Here, on the occasion of this matter, we make an exhortation to all authorities to ensure the immediate compliance of each ruling; how we would wish that we had no non-execution incidents here," he commented.
In September 2016, Paola Buenrostro, a trans woman, was murdered in Mexico City, and just a few weeks ago authorities from the Attorney General's Office of Justice arrested Arturo Felipe "N," identified as the main suspect in her death.
You may be interested in: The Judiciary does not take orders: Hugo Aguilar; facing Sheinbaum, the new Court submits its report for its first year of work / What should keep Hugo Aguilar awake at night / A year of real and true justice (sic)
Join our channel! EL UNIVERSAL is now on WhatsApp! From your mobile device, stay informed of the day's most relevant news, opinion pieces, entertainment, trends and more.
aov/bmc